US basedUS hosted
Desks
$2 / month

Comment and reply across TML.

Start or manage membership

Most pulsed

Advertisement Sinscents Bad Intentions. Great Candles.

Latest from other desks

tml.the modern leap
Food / Food Culture

Ess-a-Bagel Wins Best Bagel at BagelFest's Blind Tasting

Ess-a-Bagel, the Manhattan institution founded in 1976 and celebrating 50 years in business, won Best Bagel and Best New York Style at the sold-out 2026 New York BagelFest at Citi Field on Sunday, November 15, 2026. The festival's Breadhead Awards are decided by blind tasting — plain, unsliced bagels judged on flavor, texture, appearance and aroma — and Ess-a-Bagel beat last year's champion, Dallas-based Starship Bagel, which took silver in both categories, in a field of 27 bagel exhibitors across 14 award categories.

Plain bagels (archive), the form BagelFest judges score blind — unsliced, on flavor, texture, appearance and aroma. Ess-a-Bagel took gold in Best Bagel and Best New York Style on November 15. Photo: Politikaner, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Summary

The blind tasting is the whole argument: no signage, no schmear, nowhere to hide. A 50-year-old shop won it with the plain bagel it's been making since 1976, against a field that came from five countries to take the title away.

Tap a passage. React to the part that matters.

New York's bagel title is back in New York, and it was won the hardest way the festival offers. Ess-a-Bagel took gold in Best Bagel and Best New York Style at the 2026 New York BagelFest, held Sunday, November 15, at Citi Field and presented by King Arthur Baking Company, according to the festival's winners announcement. The seventh annual festival was sold out, with 27 bagel exhibitors and 25 additional food and beverage brands filling more than 50 booths.

The judging format strips out everything except the bagel. The Breadhead Awards are decided by blind tasting: plain, unsliced bagels, scored by culinary experts and festivalgoers on flavor, texture, appearance and aroma. There's no house style to reward, no topping to hide behind and no reputation in the room — the judges don't know whose bagel they're eating. Across 14 award categories, that format is what makes the Best Bagel title the one the field actually wants.

The runner-up tells the story of how close it was. Starship Bagel of Dallas, last year's Best Bagel champion, took silver in both Best Bagel and Best New York Style. Its founder, Oren Salomon, is Brooklyn-born, which made the final a New York argument conducted partly by proxy: the defending champion from Texas, run by a Brooklyn native, beaten by the Manhattan institution in a blind test. Hey Bagel of Seattle took bronze in Best Bagel, and Black Seed Bagels took bronze in Best New York Style.

For the winner, the timing is the headline under the headline. Ess-a-Bagel was founded in 1976 by an Austrian baking family and is celebrating 50 years in business. It won with its traditional bagel — the same style it has served since it opened — in the festival's most competitive year, which organizers described as the most contested yet, with the slimmest margins of victory in the event's history.

The rest of the winners list spread the map. California's Rise Bagels won the People's Choice award and gold for Rising Star, Bagel Joint took gold for Best Bialy — with Ess-a-Bagel taking bronze in that category too — and Bagel Brigade of Hyderabad, India, won Best International, underlining that the field of more than two dozen exhibitors came from five countries and ten states.

One judge's account of the blind panel shows how the format disciplines the judging itself. Tasters were handed pieces of more than two dozen plain bagels and scored in a single bite where they could, because palate fatigue is real across a field that size — and the final decision came down to two bagels representing opposite ideas: the nostalgic New York ideal and a modern challenger pushing at the form's edges. Nostalgia won, but narrowly, and the judge's own top score went to a third shop entirely. That's the blind format working as intended: the crown went to the consensus of palates that didn't know what they were eating, not to any single judge's favorite.

A bagel title decided by blind tasting can't be bought with a better booth or a bigger sign, and that's why this one travels. Ess-a-Bagel's two golds rest on the plainest product in the building, judged without its name attached. Fifty years in, the institution's argument is still the same one it started with: the bagel itself, with nowhere to hide.

Sources

The conversation

A little more perspective.

Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.

The conversation.

Loading comments…

Keep your curiosity going.

Some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through one, we might make a commission — it never changes what you pay. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.