Matlow Sworn In as Tallahassee Mayor With New Majority
Jeremy Matlow was set to be sworn in as Tallahassee's mayor at 5 p.m. on Monday, November 16, 2026, in the City Commission chambers, followed by a public block party outside City Hall. The November 3 election gave progressives a 3-2 majority on the five-member commission, and the new majority's first business meeting on Wednesday already carries the city manager's future and a fire services deal with Leon County.
The ceremony takes an evening. The majority starts Wednesday: a city manager whose contract was written to survive exactly this election, and a fire deal negotiated before the winners were even sworn in. Tallahassee's new government isn't waiting for a learning curve.
Tallahassee changed governments on Monday evening, and it threw a party for the occasion. Mayor-elect Jeremy Matlow was set to be sworn in at 5 p.m. on Monday, November 16, 2026, in the City Commission chambers, and the ceremony was scheduled to be followed at 6 p.m. by “The People's Block Party” outside City Hall at 300 S. Adams St., according to the inauguration announcement. The celebration's lineup included Three's Company, a band featuring newly elected City Commissioner P.J. Perez, alongside Tareef Knockout and Tallahassee Nights Live.
The party marks a genuine transfer of power. The November 3 general election flipped control of the five-member City Commission, creating a progressive 3-2 majority of Matlow, Perez and Commissioner Jack Porter. They replace the old majority built around Mayor John Dailey, who didn't run for a third term, and Commissioners Dianne Williams-Cox and Curtis Richardson. Matlow, 41, is a two-term city commissioner and co-owner of Gaines Street Pies, a small chain of Tallahassee pizza restaurants, with eight years on the commission. He defeated Loranne Ausley in the mayor's race and has promised a “180 degree” change in how commission meetings are run, starting with a more respectful and collaborative atmosphere.
The first test arrives in 48 hours. The new commission's first business meeting is Wednesday, November 18, and Matlow has put City Manager Karen Jumonville's future on its agenda — an item that appeared on the updated agenda released Monday with no detail attached. Jumonville was installed under the previous majority, and her five-year contract carries a provision requiring a 4-1 supermajority of commissioners to fire her, an arrangement agreed with the outgoing mayor that was designed to keep a new progressive majority from removing her. She has recently told Commissioner Porter she would be willing to revisit that provision, and Matlow, who has been discussing her future since election night, has said he has specific feelings he'll express to his fellow commissioners.
A second item on Wednesday's agenda was negotiated before the new commission existed. On November 12, nine days after the election, Matlow and Leon County Commissioner Christian Caban announced a proposed deal on fire services fees, ending — if both commissions approve it — a city-county fight that ran for more than a year. The pair struck the deal in a private meeting on November 10 at the mayor-elect's office. Caban called a special county commission meeting for Monday, November 16, to take up the agreement, writing that it needed immediate attention, and the city commission is scheduled to consider it Wednesday.
The reorganization itself carries one more appointment. Commissioners choose the mayor pro tem from among themselves when a new commission is seated, and Matlow has said there's a “100% chance” Porter, first elected in 2020, gets the post. Porter is the senior member of the new majority and its longest-serving progressive.
What Monday's ceremony settles is who holds the seats. What it doesn't settle is how much of the old City Hall survives contact with the new majority — the city manager's contract, the staff who served the previous commission, and a meeting culture Matlow ran against for two terms as a commissioner in the minority. The block party is the celebration. Wednesday's agenda is the governing, and it starts with the two hardest items the new majority owns: whether the manager stays, and whether the fire deal holds.
Sources
- 'People's Block Party' tonight with new Mayor Matlow, Commissioner Perez — Tallahassee Democrat, November 16, 2026
- 'The wounds run deep': Firing Tallahassee city manager may be just the start — Tallahassee Democrat, November 16, 2026
- Matlow, Caban strike fire deal days after election to avoid costly split — Tallahassee Democrat, November 12, 2026
The conversation.
Loading comments…
A little more perspective.
Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.