Burnham Calls Brexit's Costs the Obvious Truth
Prime Minister Andy Burnham will say in a London speech on Monday, November 16, that the Brexit Britain was given hasn't worked and has cost more than it gained, as he seeks a reset deal with the European Union at Friday's summit in Brussels. The expected package covers food checks and youth mobility, and Burnham says any deal has to respect Labour's manifesto red lines while giving people tangible improvements.
Burnham isn't proposing to rejoin the European Union on Friday. He's doing something his predecessor avoided: saying out loud that the current deal costs Britain money, and then asking Brussels for a better one inside the red lines Labour still won't cross.
Prime Minister Andy Burnham will use a foreign policy speech in London's financial district on Monday, November 16, to say the costs of Brexit are an “obvious truth” Britain has avoided naming. Advance excerpts released by his office have him calling for a reset of Britain's relationship with the European Union ahead of a summit in Brussels on Friday, November 20.
The line his office is leading with is blunt. “It's like the emperor's new clothes — where no one is prepared to say the obvious truth,” Burnham is set to say. “Well, I say it as I see it. And to be frank, the emperor has nothing on. The Brexit we were given has not worked. We have lost more than we gained.”
The immediate business in Brussels is narrower than the speech. Britain and the EU are expected to agree to cut border checks on food and agricultural products and to put arrangements in place that let young people live and work abroad more easily. Reporting from Dublin on November 12 put the wider package — food and farm trade, emissions trading and youth mobility — at an estimated £5.1 billion in annual economic benefits, and a draft agreement on removing food and export checks has already been reached.
Burnham's break is with his own side's recent past. His predecessor, Keir Starmer, held Labour's 2024 manifesto red lines against returning to the EU's customs union, single market or freedom of movement, and treated the Brexit settlement as closed. Burnham is set to say Friday's agreement still has to respect those red lines, which bind Labour until the next election, due in 2029, while improving the deal the previous Conservative government struck and giving people tangible improvements.
That leaves him arguing two things at once. The deal has to stay inside the manifesto lines, and the conversation about its legacy has to reopen anyway. Reuters reported that his willingness to put a broad array of longer-term options on the table reopens a debate that upended British politics when Britain voted to leave the bloc in the 2016 referendum.
Brussels has already priced the longer conversation. The BBC reported on November 8 that negotiations on the new bilateral agreement were about 90 percent complete, and that Michel Barnier, the EU's former chief Brexit negotiator, warned Britain can't pick and choose its relationship: there's no single market without accepting freedom of movement, and a returning Britain couldn't keep its historic budget rebate.
The government's own numbers are more modest than the rhetoric. Burnham has cited government figures suggesting closer ties without rejoining could add 0.4 percent to GDP, while acknowledging Britain would have to follow more EU rules as the price of that access. His office has also cited polling showing a majority of voters now support rejoining the EU, which is the political ground he is standing on as he reopens the question.
Friday's summit was scheduled for July and was postponed when Starmer resigned. What comes out of it will be read two ways: as a technical package on food checks and youth mobility that lowers costs for consumers in the short term, and as the first test of whether Burnham's longer argument — that the 2020 departure itself needs reassessing — can survive contact with the EU's terms.
The speech lands Monday evening at the Lord Mayor's Banquet. The summit follows on Friday. Between the two, Burnham has to hold a coalition that includes voters who wanted Brexit undone, voters who wanted it left alone, and a manifesto that promised not to cross the lines he's now walking up to.
Sources
The conversation.
Loading comments…

A little more perspective.
Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.