Delray Beach Drops Its St. Patrick's Day Parade
Delray Beach, Florida, has canceled the St. Patrick's Day parade it has held for nearly 60 years, after the city attorney warned that a new state law barring public money for diversity and heritage events leaves the city no legal room to host it. The law, SB 1134, takes effect on January 1, and the city is also ending its sponsorship of Pride celebrations in June.
The parade isn't short of crowds or history. It's short of a legal category. A heritage celebration that isn't a federal or state holiday now sits inside a ban written for diversity programs, and Delray Beach is the first city to say so out loud.
Delray Beach announced on November 10 that it will no longer host its St. Patrick's Day parade, a fixture of the Palm Beach County city's calendar for nearly 60 years, because a new Florida law bars local governments from spending public money on diversity, equity and inclusion activities. The law, Senate Bill 1134, takes effect on January 1. The city says it will also withdraw its sponsorship of LGBTQ Pride celebrations in June.
The decision came from the city attorney's reading of the statute, not from a budget fight. The attorney advised the mayor that a government-sponsored celebration of culture, ethnicity or heritage that isn't a national holiday could run afoul of the law, which defines the banned activities to include programs and heritage events designed with reference to ethnicity, sexual orientation or gender. Federal and state holidays, including Christmas and Martin Luther King Jr. Day celebrations, are carved out. St. Patrick's Day isn't.
The exposure is personal as well as municipal. SB 1134 provides that an official who violates the provision can face civil or legal consequences, which is the part of the law that turned a parade permit into a legal risk. Commissioner Judy Mollica said the city acted on its attorney's advice, not out of malice. City officials say they're hopeful private businesses and other private money can keep the parade alive without the city as host.
The bill itself was a Jacksonville production. SB 1134, titled "Official Actions of Local Governments," was filed by two Jacksonville Republicans, Senator Clay Yarborough and Representative Dean Black, and DeSantis signed it in April as part of his administration's campaign against diversity programs in public institutions. When he signed it, the governor's position was that Floridians shouldn't have to pay for them. Delray Beach's reading of the finished text is that a St. Patrick's Day parade is exactly the kind of ethnically referenced heritage event the text describes.
Governor Ron DeSantis, who signed the bill in April and has called DEI programs discriminatory, attacked the decision in a November 13 post, calling it "malicious compliance." The parade the city is giving up is not a small one. At the last estimate it drew up to 100,000 people to a downtown built around restaurants and bars, in the middle of the spring tourist season.
The money at stake runs in both directions. The city saves whatever it spent hosting and policing the parade. The restaurants and bars along Atlantic Avenue, the street the parade runs through, lose one of their biggest days of the year, in a month when South Florida's tourist season is at full strength. A crowd estimated at up to 100,000 doesn't move to another weekend. It disperses, and some of it doesn't come back for a replacement event at all.
That's the trade the law now forces on every Florida city with a heritage festival on its calendar. Delray Beach is simply the first to publish its answer. Any city that funds a St. Patrick's Day parade, a Juneteenth celebration that isn't run as the federal holiday, or a Pride event with taxpayer money has to make the same call before January 1, and its attorney will read the same statute.
For Delray Beach, the parade's future now runs through private hands. If businesses step in, the bands march in March without the city's name on the event. If they don't, a tradition that started around 1970 ends not with a vote against it, but with a legal opinion that hosting it had become a liability.
Sources
The conversation.
Loading comments…
A little more perspective.
Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.